You walked into your salary review confident, prepared, and armed with evidence of your contributions. But instead of the well-earned pay rise you were expecting, you got a disappointing "not this time." It’s frustrating, demotivating, and—if you’re honest—probably a bit of a confidence hit.

But let’s take a step back. In a market where top talent is in high demand, not getting a pay rise isn’t necessarily a reflection of your worth. It’s a signal—one that tells you it’s time to reassess, strategise, and take control of your career path. Here’s how you turn a rejection into an opportunity.

1. Reality Check: Have You Truly Earned it?

It’s easy to assume that tenure equals entitlement to a salary bump, but in reality, pay rises are about impact, not just time served. Before pushing back, ask yourself the hard questions:

• Have you consistently exceeded targets and expectations?
• Can you point to specific contributions that have improved revenue, efficiency, or client satisfaction?
• Have you taken on additional responsibilities that justify an increase?

If the answer is a clear "yes," then you have every reason to challenge the decision. If you’re not sure, this is a chance to refocus, refine your goals, and set yourself up for a stronger case in the next review.

2. Build a Bulletproof Case 

Most employers won’t hand out pay rises simply because you ask. You need undeniable proof of your value.

• Industry benchmarks – Research salaries for your role within the insurance sector. If you’re being underpaid, have the numbers to back it up.
• Quantifiable achievements – Have you grown a book of business, streamlined processes, or enhanced client retention? Make it measurable.
• Revenue impact – If your work directly contributes to financial growth, spell it out. Numbers are hard to argue with.

Once you’ve built your case, request a follow-up meeting with your manager. Present your evidence clearly and position yourself as an asset the business can’t afford to undervalue.

3. Look Beyond Salary – What Else Can You Negotiate?

Sometimes, a company genuinely doesn’t have the budget for pay rises. But that doesn’t mean you can’t improve your overall package.

Consider negotiating:

• Accomplishments: Flexible working (remote days, compressed hours) 
• Additional leave (extra holiday allowance)
• Professional development (funding for qualifications, training, or industry events)
• Performance bonuses (a results-based financial incentive)

These perks can sometimes have more value than a salary increase, so think strategically about what benefits would enhance your role and work-life balance.

4. Stay Professional, But Stay Hungry

A "no" today doesn’t mean "no" forever. Your response to rejection defines your career progression. Instead of letting it demotivate you, turn it into fuel.

• Ask for constructive feedback – Understand what you need to improve to secure a future increase
• Agree on measurable targets – Set clear goals with your manager so there’s no ambiguity in your next review
• Continue delivering value – The best way to earn leverage is to make yourself indispensable.

5. Know When It’s Time to Move On

If you’re consistently overlooked, underpaid, and see no path for progression, it might be time to evaluate your options.

The insurance industry is currently experiencing a talent shortage, and skilled professionals—particularly those in broking, underwriting, and claims—are in high demand. If your current employer isn’t recognising your worth, others will.

Where Do You Go From Here?

If you’re feeling stuck and want a clearer picture of your market value and career opportunities, let’s talk. As specialists in insurance recruitment, we have access to exclusive roles, salary insights, and market trends that can help you take control of your career.

Get in touch today to explore your options.

Contact Us